Im Jahr 2007 wurde ein Hamburg Blue Devils All-Star Team von den Fans gewählt. Hier die Ergebnisse der 15 Jahre Hamburg Blue Devils All-Star Wahlen:

Alltime Offense

Position Name aktive Zeit (HBD)
Quarterback Dino Bucciol 1993-1999
Runningback Sascha Gerasimov 2006-2007
Runningback Bruce Reid 1995-2000
Wide Receiver Maximilian von Garnier 1992-2008
Wide Receiver Babak Movassaghi 1999-2002
Wide Receiver Julian Spohr 2003-aktuell
Tight End Andreas Nommensen 1998-2006
Offensive Line Julian Pjanic 2001-2007
Offensive Line Christian Thielck 1998-2007
Offensive Line Toni Söker 1994-2000
Offensive Line Oliver Kirchhoff 1994-2004
Offensive Line Benjamin Crljenkovic 2001-2004, 2007

Alltime Defense

Position Name aktive Zeit (HBD)
Defensive Back Rico Meinhardt 1997-2007
Defensive Back Christopher Malewski 1995-2002, 2007
Defensive Back Toure Butler 2003-2005, 2009-2010
Linebacker Robert Koster 2001-2007, 2011
Linebacker John van Look 1995-2006, aktuell
Linebacker Matthias Ude 1993-2001
Linebacker Jan Hendrik Wohlers 1994-2004
Defensive Line Vlady Ilic 1993-1997, 1999, 2001-2004
Defensive Line Bernhard Rozic 1996-1997, 1999-2003
Defensive Line Campino Milligan 1996-2002
Defensive Line Jens Allers 1998-2004

Special Teams

Position Name aktive Zeit (HBD)
Kicker Timo Erbs 1996-1999, 2001-2002,